Articles and Resources for Becoming an Urban Beekeeper
How to Start Urban Beekeeping: The Importance of Honey
By Michael Lewis 4/3/14 Money Crashers
The bee has always occupied a special place in man’s psyche. Young children learn the origins of babies with stories of “the birds and the bees,” while their industry is so respected that a person engaged in intense activity is “as busy as a bee.” “Spelling bees” and “quilting bees” are so named because a meeting of people working together resembles the scenes within a beehive. Closely guarded information is “none of your beeswax,” and the flappers of the 1920s popularized the “bee’s knees” to express the coolness of an object or activity.
We have seen girls with “bee-stung lips,” and refer to irritated people as having a “bee in their bonnet.” And who hasn’t made a “beeline” for a special object?
As far as we know, bees have been around for about 125 million years. They are descendants of wasps, most of which are predator carnivores. Bees, however, switched from hunting prey to collecting pollen for food – a nice adaptation, since the food doesn’t fight back. Scientists have since classified nearly 20,000 species of bees, and they are found on every continent except Antarctica. They are the most efficient pollination agents in nature, a critical factor in the appearance of the world as we know it.
The Honey Bee, a European Transplant
While most bees pollinate flowers – the bumblebee, for example, is especially important in the pollination of tomatoes and glasshouse-raised crops – the western honey bee is the bee people are most likely to name when asked the identity of the greatest pollinator. The honey bee originated in Asia, traveled to Europe, and was introduced into North America in the early 1600s. Italian bees were brought to this country from Italy in 1859, and later from Spain, Portugal, and elsewhere. In 1990, a subspecies from Africa came to America.
Western honey bees live in colonies of up to 80,000 bees with one queen bee, a small proportion of drones (male bees) whose sole purpose is to fertilize a new queen, and thousands and thousands of workers bees, most of whom live about three months. On average, about 1% of worker bees die each day so a hive is newly populated every three to four months. Fortunately, queen bees are exceptionally productive, laying as many as 2,000 to 2,500 eggs per day.
Honey bees digest flower nectar and pollen, which is converted into honey by their digestive system and subsequently serves as a food source for the bees during non-growing seasons. As a result of selective breeding over the centuries, honey bees produce much more honey than they consume. The amount of honey produced by a hive varies considerably by region and weather conditions, since bees also consume the honey for food. An average production may be 40 to 100 pounds per hive per year, but there are no guarantees since conditions per hive can vary significantly.
According to the National Honey Board, 147 million pounds of honey were produced in 2012, with a retail value of $286.9 million. Beekeepers in North and South Dakota produce almost 40% of the total volume of commercial honey in the country. On the other hand, Americans consume more than 400 million pounds of honey annually, resulting in a large import volume. Home use and commercial use is about 50/50.
In addition to honey, honey bees also produce several other widely used products:
- Beeswax: Used in the manufacture of candles and seals.
- Propolis: Used by bees as a sealant in the hives, but gathered and sold for wood finishes and other uses.
- Royal Jelly: Produced by worker bees and fed to bee larvae. It is sometimes marketed as a “health food,” but can cause severe allergies.
The Importance of Bees in Life as We Know It
More than 100 agricultural crops are pollinated by bees, ranging from watermelons to apples. The U.S. Department of Agriculture has estimated that 80% of insect pollination is done by the Western honey bee, primarily because they are the only species that can be easily managed and moved around, and can exploit a wide variety of crops. In Arizona alone, honey bees are responsible for almost $7 billion of agricultural crops, according to the University of Arizona’s Africanized Honey Bee Education Project. And the California almond industry, employing 800,000 acres and producing 80% of the world’s production of almonds, is entirely dependent upon honey bees, according to theWestern Farm Press.
Every February, about one million hives are trucked into California to supplement the 500,000 hives of Californian beekeepers necessary to pollinate the crop worth about $4 billion each year. The importance of bees in the cycle of life has been noted over the centuries. Notably, Charles Darwin proclaimed, “The life of man would be made extremely difficult if the bee disappeared.” Albert Einstein is often attributed with the quote, “If the bee disappears from the surface of the earth, man would have no more than four years to live.”
According to Elizabeth Grossman, writing in Yale Environment 360, “One of every three bites of food eaten worldwide depends upon pollinators, especially bees, for a successful harvest.” Maria Boland, writing in a 2010 article for Mother Nature Network, was more succinct: “Essentially, if honey bees disappear, they could take most of our insect pollinated plants with them, potentially reducing mankind to little more than a water diet.” A scary thought if extinction is possible – but is it realistic?
Are Honey Bees Becoming Extinct?
According to the USDA, beekeepers began reporting losses of 30% to 90% of their hives in 2006. While a certain number of hives are lost every year, the scale of recent losses is unusual. Even before the most recent losses, the honey bee population has been in a long-term decline, from an estimated 5 million hives in the 1940s to approximately 2.5 million today. At the same time, the demand for hives by the agricultural industry continues to increase.
The unusual losses, commonly referred to as colony collapse disorder (CCD), have been studied for years without yet being able to identify a single cause. According to a 2006 National Academy of Sciences report, the population of wild bees and other natural pollinators have also trended downward in recent years, although sufficient data to make absolutely definitive statements is lacking.
Despite efforts to link the population declines to a single cause, most researchers believe it is the result of a combination of five main factors:
- Pathogens. While no single virus or bacteria has been directly correlated with CCD, higher totals of pathogens have been found in collapsed colonies.
- Parasites. Varroa mites only reproduce in a honey bee colony and weaken the bee by spreading RNA viruses on the merging pupae. Miticides have been used for control, but approximately 5% of mites develop immunity, eliminating its efficacy on future generations.
- Management Stressors. Hives of bees are frequently transported across the country to pollinate large food crops and located in close proximity causing overcrowding. This stresses the bees and makes them more vulnerable to disease.
- Environmental Stressors. Increased urbanization reduces sources of pollen and nectar, and large crops of a single variety limit diversity and provide lower nutritional value. Furthermore, limited access to water or contaminated water contributes to CCD.
- Pesticides. Neonicotinoid pesticides are thought to be a factor, but there is dispute about whether research supports this.
Many scientists have concluded that a single cause of CCD is unlikely, but is more likely the result of a “perfect storm,” where all of the factors play a part. Some observers believe that cries of extinction are exaggerated, noting their financial value to agriculture in general. They suggest that domesticated honey bees in particular will be saved through genetic modification and greater reliance on human-supplied sugar as a substitute for pollen and nectar to ensure an adequate number of bees for commercial pollination. However, such measures will not save wild bees or unmanaged honey beehives from continued threats to survival.
The Rise of Urban Beekkeepers
Urban beekeeping was banned in many cities after World War II, as municipalities sought to distance themselves from their agricultural past. A second wave of restrictions followed the publication of “killer bee invasions” from South America and lurid tales of people and animals being chased and stung to death by merely being close to a hive.
However, as fear began to subside with reality, beekeeping began to appear in cities of all sizes. Beginning in the late 1990s, the popularity of natural foods and a desire to return to simpler, more agrarian times led to the increasing presence of beehives in urban areas. Hives on rooftops, balconies, and gardens in all five boroughs of New York City began to appear in 2010, following the lifting of the ban on beekeeping. According to the founding director of the New York City Beekeepers Association Andrew Coté, quoted on the CNN blog Eatocracy, beekeeping in the city has enjoyed “exponential growth.”
Other major cities already allowing beehives within their limits include Chicago, Denver, Salt Lake City, San Francisco, Seattle, Atlanta, Washington, D.C., and Dallas. Los Angeles and other communities are currently studying laws and deciding whether to allow beekeeping in their communities. According to Kim Flottum, editor of “Bee Culture” magazine, there were an estimated 125,000 amateur apiarists (beekeepers) nationwide in 2011, a population that has substantially grown in recent years.
While many more municipilaties allow beekeeping activity, veteran beekeepers note that in those that have restrictions forbidding beekeeping, the laws are rarely enforced unless a complaint is received. For that reason, they suggest maintaining hives out of site and surrounded by six-foot fences or nearby shrubbery.
Veteran beekeepers are often willing to help novices get started, liberally sharing their time and knowledge through local beekeeping associations. Your first step should be to locate an association near your residence and contact one of the local beekeepers. Many associations run regular classes on beekeeping, and it is a good place to find other enthusiasts.
The time to start new colonies is between January and May, depending upon the season where you live. If you start too early, the bees will not be able to find food and keep warm; if you start too late, they lose the opportunity to make honey and miss the first surge of nectar. You should also keep it simple, following basic beekeeping methods without experimentation. You will have time enough for that when you gain experience and confidence.
Use the following plan to start your first colonies.
1. Identify the Location of Your Hives Before Ordering
A typical hive forages more than 8,000 square yards, depending upon the availability of flowering plants. It is not necessary to locate your hives adjacent to a garden, but a constant supply of clean water is essential. Furthermore, you should avoid locations next to footpaths, or other areas where people are likely to gather or walk. It is generally a good idea to keep the hives out of sight to avoid problems with neighbors.
2. Limit Initial Purchases
Start simply and learn the basics with the following essentials, all of which are available from numerous suppliers over the Internet:
- Hives. Commercially made beehives replicate the conditions found in natural beehives, but facilitate management of the bees and honey harvesting. There are a number of configurations ($80 to $160) available depending upon the number of frames and construction materials, but all consist of at least a landing strip/board for bees to land and enter the hive, a bottom board, a brood box for the queen to lay eggs, boxes where honey is stored (called “supers”), frames for honeycomb, and an outer cover. Many beekeepers recommend placing the hives on support above ground to minimize moisture (which causes rot) and invasion by mice.
- Bees. Most experts recommend Italian bees for beginners, although some suggest Russians or Carniolans. All three varieties are known for their gentleness, production, and ease of management. Bees can be purchased online or from local bee farms. Some suppliers require that you pick up bees, rather than having them shipped, so you need to check with potential sellers about their restrictions. While bees can be purchased in packages of 9,000 to 20,000 bees with the Queen bee in its own package ($110 to $140) , beginning beekeepers should purchase a starter hive called a “nuc hive” ($180 to $210) that consists of four or five frames of bees and a queen. Buying a nuc ensures that the bees are related to the queen and already working as a hive.
- Smoker. Bees are evolutionary trained to anticipate a wildfire and the destruction of the hive whenever they smell smoke. Anticipating escape, they instinctively enter the hive and begin consuming as much honey as possible for the energy to flee and find a new nest. Smoke also interferes with the natural chemical communication between bees, causing confusion and slowed reactions. When a smoker ($30 to $45) - a simple cylinder with bellows attached – is directed into the hive, the bees become occupied, leaving you pretty much alone to do any necessary work, such as cleaning the hive or harvesting honey.
- Protective Gear. For most beekeeping activities, a simple veil and hat ($35 to $45) is what most keepers use to keep bees out of their hair. Some use a light jacket with a veil ($54 to $60). Beginning beekeepers often use a full bee suit ($75 to $90) and gloves ($18 to $25) until they become accustomed to working with bees, especially if the weather is not right or the bees are feeling feisty. You should wear whatever makes you comfortable so that you enjoy working with the bees. Usually, as you gain experience, you will begin to wear less protective gear.
Some companies offer a complete beginner’s kit, complete with a hive, protective gear, smoker, tools, and a beginner’s DVD with instruction book at prices starting around $220. Bought separately, these items would cost approximately $300 to $400.
3. Consider Two Colonies, But No More in the Beginning
Many beekeepers recommend starting with two colonies, rather than one, since you can compare one to the other and assist the weaker one by transferring bees and brood from the healthier hive if necessary. As time goes by, many fledgling beekeepers add multiple hives, often expanding throughout the neighborhood to plant new colonies.
4. Plan on Spending at Least a Half Hour Per Week Beekeeping
This enables you to keep up the health of the hive and correct any problems. Bees generally take care of themselves, so you will probably spend no more than 30 to 40 hours per year looking out for them if you have done a good job locating the hives.
Africanized bees have invaded the lower parts of the United States in recent years. While smaller than the western honey bee, they are much more aggressive and may pursue a perceived attacker for a quarter-mile or more. They nest frequently in the ground and tend to swarm more frequently than the honey bee. Also, they are not as efficient honey makers as the western honey bee.
First year -- Building Foundation
Activities which will establish the foundation of knowledge and experience to help you keep bees.
1.) Education -- take courses through your local beekeeping association in order to assess your interest and willingness to make the time and financial commitment.
2.) Education (cont.) -- read, consult, and watch. Read books, academic, and popular literature related to bees, talk to other beekeepers, and watch documentaries and youtube videos. You should have an almost encyclopedic knowledge of diseases, lifecycles, social orders, problems, population management, equipment, and a system for handling the volume of information you'll be acquiring. You will also need to spend some time getting to know local industries and businesses, too. The florist down the street might not mind your bees, and you may not mind the pollen or nectar from the flowers, but you might have trouble with the maraschino cherry factory across the river.
3.) Affiliate with Associations -- become affiliated with your local beekeeping association and volunteer or sponsor member hives. Urban associations have often lobbied hard for the ability to legally keep bees; keeping in defiance of their efforts or the law can jeopardize everyone's ability.(Purchase gloves and a helmet and veil at this point, although a white shirt and khakis are fine until you've made the final commitment and choose to purchase a bee suit)
4.) Work Bees -- Lease hives or hive space from a beekeeper with registered apiaries in order to work bees or collect honey. (Purchase a smoker and hive tools at this point)
5.) Education (others) -- Introduce the topic casually in order to assess the reception. Invest the time in educating your neighbors and friends about bees. Talk about bees, share honey, plant a pollinator garden, and teach your neighbors and friends how to predict the movement of bees and wasps and how to move and act around species of Hymenoptera. Show your neighbors and local pollinators your commitment. If they are antithetic to living near bees you may need to continue to lease space or hives or determine what your rights are and continue despite your neighbors' objections. If you don't even dare broach the topic with your neighborhood, spend time getting to know the property and (this sounds creepy) your neighbors' ability to view your property. If you can site your bees where they will be unobserved, that is your best option. A section of fence, tall shrubbery, or another structure can shield your activity and the bees activity. Most people are unaware of the difference between a honeybee and other flying insects, but they'll catch on to you trotting outside in your bee suit.
Activities which will demonstrate your commitment, compliance, and concern.
1.) Boxes -- Purchase or build your boxes and frames
2.) Packet or Swarm -- Purchase a packet of bees or register your name on a swarm list (through your local beekeeping association) or keep everyone in the area aware that you're interested in catching a swarm.
3.) Register -- operate in compliance with local laws and/or regulations. You will be fond of your bees, I would imagine that having god-knows-what-state-agency removing your bees from your premises for non-compliance would be wrenching.
4.) Install -- prior to installing your bees, site your bees according to their needs. Have a clear flight path, nearby source of water (they will visit children's pools, my toddler learned to carefully pull honeybees out of her hair when she was a year old. However, if your reluctant neighbors have a pool, birdbath, or hummingbird feeder, anticipate problems and be prepared to work out a solution), and a windbreak. If your neighbors are opposed, but unable to do much more than complain, screen your hives and site them further from the angry neighbors.
5.) Monitor -- checking your bees is a science, you have to be methodical, relaxed, and unrushed. There are plenty of sources which discuss methods, and hopefully if you've shadowed an experienced keeper for a year, you'll have experience. You can test your observation skills before you have access to bees by watching a hivecam or looking at high-res photos of working comb. You're looking for brood, brood pattern, honey, capped honey, infestations, and general health of all hive members. Record your information.
6.) Sweeten -- keep your neighbors in honey (when/if you have it) or invite them for coffee and a morning (safe distance/out of flight path) observation. (Rent or borrow extraction equipment the first two or three years, since you may not even harvest right away.)
Personal note: It's not worth keeping bees on your property/rooftop if you'll be stressed about the neighbors, it's just as fun and interesting to visit and work your bees at another location where they are received more warmly. I began "studying" to keep bees about six years before I worked my first hive. I rented a small house in the city, and I considered a lot of issues when I lived there. Ultimately, I purchased property outside of the city limits in order to keep bees and a few other animals. I still manage a pollinator garden in a dense urban area, but my current neighbors (in an area of just under a thousand people per square mile, which is technically urban) are receptive of my bees. "Lousy drunks, your bees are!" was the last comment that I heard when my bees depleted my neighbors' hummingbird feeder.
Education and/or Equipment Resources:
Benjamin, Allison and Brian Mccallum (2011) Bees in the City: the Urban Beekeeper's Handbook.London: Guardian Books. http://www.amazon.com/Bees-City-...
Conrad, Ross (2007) Natural Beekeeping: Organic Approaches to Modern Apiculture. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green Publishing. http://www.amazon.com/Natural-Be... (Our copy is kept on the coffee table)
Flottum, Kim and Kathy Summers (1997) The New Starting Right with Bees. Medina, Ohio: AI Root Co. http://www.amazon.com/New-Starti... (Our copy is kept in our reading room, ahem).
Note: some of these are dated, since research is ongoing.
Silence of the Bees http://www.pbs.org/wnet/nature/e...
Vanishing of the Bees http://www.vanishingbees.com/
Who Killed the Honeybee http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/...
How do I become a beekeeper?
Apiculture (Beekeeping): Is there a resource to find beekeepers in your local area?
http://www.agnic.org/ (OSU AgNIC contribution http://osu.campusguides.com/agni...)
American Beekeeping Federation
American Honey Producers Association
Bush Farms--Beekeeping Naturally
Cornell's Hive and Honeybee
HoneyO (State Honey and Beekeeping Associations)
North American Pollinator Protection Program
NYTimes Articles about Bees
Wired Articles about Bees
Keeping Bees in Cities Could Be BAD for the Bees